After rumors begin to circulate that Reed killed Cheyenne, Reed is kicked out of Billings. She knows the only way to get her life back is to figure out who really murdered Cheyenne.
Carrie gets upset when her mother gives her lucky T-shirt to Help India; now she's only having bad luck, so she decides to travel halfway around the world to get her lucky shirt back.
Explains the origins of the Billings girls and how they became witches, beginning with the arrival of sixteen-year-old Elizabeth Williams at the Billings School for Girls in September, 1915.
Arianna Osgood should be in Vermont with her boyfriend but she is stranded at Easton with Thomas Pearson and someone is watching them.
With the arrest of Josh Hollis for the murder of Thomas Pearson, everything at Easton Academy is getting back to normal, but Reed is certain of Josh's innocence and determined to find the killer.
Four friends compete for the Treemont scholarship.